Data Withdrawal Experiments



TOVS 1B RAOBTemp RAOB Wind
1B_QC (Control) Y Y Y
NTVQC N Y Y
1BNTMPQC Y N Y
1BNWINQC Y Y N
NTVNTMPQC N N Y
NTVNWINQC N Y N


Data withdrawal experiment

MODEL: March 99 NCEP MRF

Resolution: t62 28 level

Period: 1 Jan 1993-28 Feb 1993

Control: With TOVS and all conventional data



Time average of 500hPa height RMSE from Control





NH 20N-60N February 1993.

Withdraw Average Spread
TOVS 1B 4.8 0.8
RAOB Temp 5.5 0.7
RAOB Wind 7.0 0.6


SH 20S-60S February 1993.

Withdraw Average Spread
TOVS 1B 22.6 3.7
RAOB Temp 6.5 0.9
RAOB Wind 5.8 0.7